"Would you like oatmeal or yogurt and toast for breakfast?" a mother asks her 5 year old.
"I'll have sugar frosties," the child answers.
Mom replies, "Your choices are oatmeal or yogurt and toast."
"Ok, I'll just have yogurt and toast."
Notice how Mom's question limits the girl's breakfast choices. Why does she ask it that way? Because otherwise the child might eat sugar frosties every morning!
This story illustrates the subtle ways that we use questions to control a conversation and limit choices for the other person. For a child this may be the proper thing to do. However, if you listen carefully to yourself and others, we do the same thing all day long. And we may not even be aware we are doing it.
Limited Choices
"Would you like to go to a movie tonight?"
"Do you think Emma or Daniel could help you?"
"Are you working on your class preparation this afternoon?"
Closed questions, right? So open them up and get your limiting ideas out of the way:
"What would you like to do tonight?"
"Who could help you?"
"When will you do your class preparation?"
Guard Rails
We put up "guard rails" to keep the other person within the boundaries that we consider to be logical, effective, or "safe." For example, rather than asking questions about completely starting a project over, we ask questions about only incremental changes. Or visa-versa.
Consciously or unconsciously our thinking, our ideas, our trust of the other person leaks into our questions. When we put up "guard rails" we try to steer others in the direction we want them to go. How much do you trust people to choose their own path and put forward their own choices?
Our questions have the power to expand the other person's thinking, or limit it.
How About You?
- Listen to your questions today. Are you limiting choices?
- What "guard rails" are you using with other people?
- Look for opportunities to "trust" others more in your conversations. See what happens!